Once upon a time I was in a museum in the east of Poland where a number of beautiful icons had been put on display. The text on the icons was in Greek. A Russian companion asked me to read the names aloud, as she had difficulty grasping the Greek alphabet. When I read aloud the name of Saint Pantaleon, she immediately crossed herself. This fourth-century martyr from Nicomedia (in modern Turkey) is considered the patron saint of physicians, and this companion happened to be a physician herself. Pantaleon became especially popular in the Eastern Orthodox Church. Later his cult also spread to the Latin west, where in Venice the church of San Pantalon – Pantaleon in the Venetian dialect – is dedicated to him. The propagation to Venice was perhaps partly the result of the strong ties that had for centuries existed between the Venetians on the one hand and the Eastern Roman or Byzantine Empire on the other. Note that the church is co-dedicated to Saint Juliana, a female martyr who was also from Nicomedia and lived in the same age. Historically the two martyrs are unrelated, except for their place of origin, but their legends have become intertwined.
History
According to tradition the church was founded in the ninth century, but the first evidence of its existence dates from the second half of the twelfth century. At some point the San Pantalon was rebuilt and then re-consecrated in 1305. The church had a classical orientation towards the east, with the Campo San Pantalon along the long south side of the building. In the seventeenth century the church was rebuilt once more, this time by Francesco Comino. Not much is known about his life. His years of birth and death are for instance a mystery. What we do know is that he was from Treviso, and the San Pantalon is without a doubt his most important work in Venice. Comino took the audacious decision to change the orientation of the church from west-east to south-north, with the façade on the side of the Campo San Pantalon. This façade consists of naked brick only: I could not spot even the tiniest decoration. It is quite clear that this part of the church was never completed.
Francesco Comino worked on the church between 1668 and 1686. In the eighteenth century several important elements were added to the building. Between 1704 and 1732 the architect Giovanni Scalfarotto (1672-1764) built the present campanile of the San Pantalon. The tower is rather slender and its conspicuous top part was executed in white. It can be seen very well from the bell-tower of the San Marco (photo above). The two chapels on the left side behind the church are eighteenth-century additions as well. These chapels are the Cappella del Sacro Chiodo (Chapel of the Sacred Nail) from 1722 and the Cappella della Santa Casa di Loreto from 1744-1745. In the first chapel a nail of the Cross of Christ is kept, the second chapel is a replica of the Holy House of Mary in the Marche. The latter chapel is attributed to Tommaso Scalfarotto, a fairly unknown architect who may have been either a nephew or a son of Giovanni Scalfarotto. That the two men were relatives is in any case certain.
Fumiani’s ceiling
The church is best known because of its ceiling. This was decorated in a rather unusual way by the Baroque painter Giovanni Antonio Fumiani (ca. 1645-1710). In a whopping 24 years, between 1680 and 1704, Fumiani painted an immense work depicting the martyrdom and glory of Saint Pantaleon. This work is not a fresco; Fumiani’s work was painted on canvas. Some 40 empty canvases (44 according to some sources, but I did not count them) were sewn together and attached to a wooden frame on the ceiling. Fumiani and his assistants then climbed a scaffold and began painting the enormous surface of 443 square meters. It would perhaps have been easier to first paint the individual canvases and then sew them together and hang the completed painting, but that procedure would no doubt have led to less fluent transitions between the various parts of the work (the seams between the individual canvases are still visible, but this is not disfiguring at all). The story that the painter, having almost finished his work, fell down the scaffold and died, is an urban myth. In reality Fumiani died six years after completing this capolavoro.
Fumiani’s creation reminded me of the work of his contemporary Andrea Pozzo (1642-1709) in the church of Sant’Ignazio di Loyola in Rome. In terms of composition, the martyrdom and glory of Saint Pantaleon resembles Pozzo’s ceiling fresco of the Apotheosis of Saint Ignatius of Loyola – that work is indeed a fresco –, but Pozzo also painted an imitation dome for the aforementioned Roman church, and this he did on canvas. Fumiani’s work is unfortunately rather dark, and the lack of light in the church itself makes it difficult to see all the details well. However, the base narrative of the painting is clear. Pantaleon is a physician who is condemned to death by the Roman emperor (presumably Galerius, who was a notorious persecutor of Christians). The death sentence is followed by his martyrdom and apotheosis (in the centre). Around the scenes the various virtues have been painted.
Other things to see
The church has a beautiful high altar by Giuseppe Sardi (1624-1699), which was made between 1668 and 1671. This high altar replaced a previous altar by Andrea Palladio (1508-1580), which has unfortunately not been preserved. Above the high altar hangs a wooden crucifix, beautifully painted by an anonymous fourteenth-century artist that is commonly referred to as the Maestro di San Pantalon. On either side of the crucified Christ we see, as usual, the Virgin Mary and Saint John. Above the Saviour an angel has been painted holding a globus cruciger, a globe with a cross. I had previously seen a similar image in the church of San Giacomo dell’Orio in Venice. That crucifix is attributed to Paolo Veneziano (ca. 1300-1365), and we may assume that the anonymous Maestro di San Pantalon was influenced by Paolo. At the end of World War Two the crucifix was stolen and sold. It was not until 2012 that the work was tracked down in Germany. A few years later it was returned to the place where it belongs.
In the church I stumbled upon a beautiful bust of Christ the Saviour. It is attributed to Cristoforo Solari (ca. 1460-1527), nicknamed Il Gobbo, the hunchback. A question mark was added to his name, so apparently the people who administer the San Pantaleon are not entirely sure. Meanwhile I was urgently looking for one of these administrators, as I was really eager to see the Cappella del Sacro Chiodo. One of my travel guides had highly recommended this chapel. The guide claimed that visitors needed to ask for permission to visit the chapel, while other sources mentioned an entrance fee. I had already found the entrance to the chapel, in the back left, but it had been roped off. When I had finally found an administrator, the rope turned out to be a wooden beam, which could be opened like a barrier. I already mentioned that it can be very dark in this church… There was libero ingresso, free entrance, but donations are obviously appreciated.
To be honest, I found the works in the Cappella del Sacro Chiodo even more interesting than Fumiani’s enormous painting. The chapel is crammed with works from the fourteenth and fifteenth centuries. The three painted panels above the entrance were once part of a single altarpiece. We see a Madonna and Child and four scenes from their lives. According to the information panel in the chapel the panels can be dated to ca. 1330. They were supposedly painted by Paolo Veneziano, but the painter may very well have been a pupil or follower of Paolo (again the Maestro di San Pantalon?). Very colourful and impressive is the other panel painting in the chapel, a Coronation of the Virgin from 1444. It is a coproduction of Giovanni d’Alemagna (died 1450) and Antonio Vivarini (died ca. 1480). As his name indicates, Giovanni d’Alemagna was originally from Germany. He married the sister of Antonio Vivarini and then frequently collaborated with his brother-in-law until his death.
In the centre of the lower margin the panel painting has a text from which we may conclude that a third person was involved in its creation. A certain Cristoforo da Ferrara carved the wooden frame into which the panel was inserted. The frame was unfortunately lost. The text then mentions Johannes and Antonius of Murano, i.e. Giovanni d’Alemagna and Antonio Vivarini, who had their studio on the island of Murano. The Coronation of the Virgin takes place on a wooden platform that has been placed inside a building that closely resembles a theatre with boxes. Dozens of saints are witnesses to the ceremony. They have all been painted as individuals, and in spite of the absence of captions they are usually instantly recognisable. At the base of the platform the four evangelists have been painted, accompanied by their familiar symbols (eagle, lion, man, ox). The evangelists are flanked by the four Church fathers, Saints Jerome and Gregorius the Great (left) and Saints Augustinus and Ambrosius (right).
The other artworks in the chapel are sculptures. The altar was made by a Venetian sculptor and dates from ca. 1380-1390. The Entombment at the foot of the altar was made in the late fourteenth century by a French sculptor, as were the Madonna and Child that we find to the left of the Coronation of the Virgin. Behind a little door in the altar the Holy Nail is kept.[1] The Latin text on the door confirms this with the text CLAVUS PEDUUM D.N.I.C., or Nail of the Feet of Our Lord Jesus Christ.
The friendly custodian wanted to be sure that I had also seen the second chapel, the Cappella della Santa Casa di Loreto. Apparently this chapel is frequently skipped by visitors. I kind of understand this. Although the fairly accurate replica of the Holy House of Mary is not bad at all, it is anything but unique in Italy (see for instance Brescia: Santa Maria della Carità). The frescoes in the chapel – also replicas of the works in Loreto – were painted by Pietro Longhi (1701-1785).
Sources: Capitol travel guide Venice & Veneto (2012), p. 104, Trotter travel guide Northeast Italy (2016), p. 394, The Churches of Venice: San Pantalon and the information panels in the church.
Note
[1] One of my travel guides claims that the original nail was stolen in 2010.






